What Are Tariffs?

A tariff is a tax imposed by a government on goods and services imported from other countries. The primary purpose of a tariff is to raise the price of imported goods, making them less competitive compared to domestically produced goods. Tariffs are a form of trade barrier that can influence the flow of goods between countries, shaping international commerce and domestic economies.

Tariffs are typically levied as a percentage of the value of the imported goods (ad valorem tariffs) or as a fixed fee per unit (specific tariffs). Governments may impose tariffs for various reasons, ranging from protecting nascent industries to generating revenue.

A Brief History of Tariffs

Early Tariffs and the Age of Mercantilism

The origins of tariffs can be traced back to ancient trade routes, where governments levied taxes on goods crossing borders. However, tariffs became particularly important during the Age of Mercantilism (16th to 18th century), a period when nations sought to accumulate wealth by controlling trade and ensuring a favorable balance of exports over imports. Nations viewed wealth in terms of bullion (gold and silver),and tariffs were seen as a tool for encouraging exports while discouraging imports.

Industrial Revolution and Protectionism

During the Industrial Revolution (18th-19th century), many countries implemented tariffs to protect emerging industries from foreign competition. As domestic industries grew, tariffs helped shield them from cheaper foreign goods, enabling them to establish a competitive edge. The British Corn Laws (1815-1846) serve as an example, where tariffs on imported grain protected domestic agricultural interests, though these laws were eventually repealed amid widespread economic debate.

The Role of Tariffs in the 20th Century

The 20th century saw a shift toward more liberal trade policies with the formation of international institutions like the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) in 1947, later evolving into the World Trade Organization (WTO). The goal was to reduce global tariffs and promote free trade.

However, protectionist measures, including tariffs, were still used as political tools in various countries throughout the century, especially during periods of economic uncertainty or when industries faced challenges from foreign competition.

How Do Tariffs Work?

Types of Tariffs

1. Ad Valorem Tariffs: These tariffs are calculated as a percentage of the value of the imported goods. For example, a 10% tariff on a car worth $20,000 would result in a tariff of $2,000.
2. ‍Specific Tariffs: These are fixed fees imposed on specific quantities or weights of goods. For instance, a tariff might charge $50 per ton of steel imported.
3. ‍Compound Tariffs: A combination of ad valorem and specific tariffs, often used when dealing with complex products or to ensure a baseline protection regardless of value.

The Process of Implementing Tariffs

Governments may impose tariffs as a response to trade imbalances, economic needs, or political reasons. The process typically involves:

• Legislation or Trade Agreements: Tariffs are often established through international trade agreements (e.g., GATT, WTO) or domestic laws.
• ‍Collection: Tariffs are collected at customs when goods cross national borders, often by customs officials.
• ‍Revenue Use: Governments may use the revenue generated from tariffs to fund domestic projects or reduce budget deficits.

Economic Theories on Tariffs

Protectionism: Why Tariffs Are Good

Supporters of tariffs argue that they can benefit a country's economy, particularly in the following ways:

• Protection of Infant Industries: Emerging industries often struggle to compete with established foreign firms. Tariffs provide temporary protection, allowing domestic companies to grow and become competitive over time.
• ‍Job Creation: Tariffs can protect jobs in industries that would otherwise be undercut by cheaper imports, preserving employment in sectors such as manufacturing.‍
• National Security: Countries may use tariffs to protect industries vital to national security, such as defense-related manufacturing.
• ‍Revenue Generation: For governments, tariffs are a source of revenue, especially in developing countries where other forms of taxation may be underdeveloped.

Free Trade: The Case Against Tariffs

Critics of tariffs, particularly proponents of free trade, argue that tariffs lead to inefficiency and economic distortions:

• Higher Prices for Consumers: Tariffs often result in higher prices for consumers, as imported goods become more expensive. This reduction in consumer purchasing power can have a negative effect on overall economic welfare.
• ‍Retaliation and Trade Wars: The imposition of tariffs can lead to retaliation from other countries, creating trade wars that harm all parties involved. For example, the US-China trade war (2018-2020) led to significant tariff hikes, hurting businesses and consumers in both countries.‍
• Distortion of Market Efficiency: Tariffs interfere with the principle of comparative advantage, where countries specialize in the production of goods they can produce most efficiently. Tariffs can lead to inefficient resource allocation and decreased overall welfare.

The Balance: Strategic Use of Tariffs

Many economists argue that tariffs should be used strategically rather than as a blanket protectionist measure. For instance, temporary tariffs might be used to address unfair trade practices or dumping(selling goods below cost to drive out competitors). Similarly, tariffs might be employed in trade negotiations, where they can be reduced in exchange for favorable terms in a trade agreement.

‍

Benefits of Tariffs

Protection of Domestic Industries

 Tariffs allow domestic producers to compete with foreign competition by increasing the cost of imported goods. This protection can be vital for industries in their infancy or those that are particularly sensitive to foreign market dynamics.

Job Preservation 

In industries like steel, textiles, and agriculture, tariffs help preserve jobs that may otherwise be lost to cheaper foreign labor or production methods.

National Security Concerns

Strategic sectors, such as defense or energy, are often protected by tariffs to ensure that a country maintains the ability to produce critical goods within its own borders.

Revenue Generation for Governments

Tariffs can serve as a significant revenue stream, especially for governments in developing economies, where alternative forms of taxation may be more difficult to implement or enforce.

Drawbacks of Tariffs

Higher Consumer Prices

The most immediate and visible effect of tariffs is the increase in the price of imported goods. These higher prices often result in inflationary pressures, reducing the purchasing power of consumers and lowering their standard of living.

Trade Wars and Retaliation

Tariffs often provoke retaliatory measures from trading partners, leading to escalating trade wars. This dynamic can result in a spiral of economic harm, reducing global trade volumes and economic growth.

Distortion of Market Efficiency

Tariffs undermine the principle of comparative advantage, causing resources to be allocated inefficiently. Rather than specializing in industries where they have a cost advantage, countries may focus on industries where they do not have a comparative advantage, reducing overall global efficiency.

The Impact on Global Supply Chains

Tariffs can disrupt global supply chains, particularly in industries where products are assembled from parts sourced from multiple countries. Tariffs can increase costs for businesses and lead to disruptions in production. 

Today’s Tariff Policy

As of typing, many of these tariffs can change, as they have for the first two-plus months of the new Trump Administration. But let’s take a quick walk through what has happened, what to expect (other than the unexpected) and what it means as far as we know.

From the first day of his term until the time of this writing, the Trump administration has imposed tariffs, threatened tariffs, enacted tariffs, and dropped them. It has been a busy time to try and keep up. So let us look at what is in place right now, and why April 2nd is a big day.

Enacted:

• Any goods not compliant with the USMCA (United States-Mexico-Canada trade agreement) are taxed at 25%(started on March 4th)
• Blanket tariffs on China at 20% (started on March 4th)
• Energy and fertilizer from Canada not compliant with USMCA taxed at 10% (started on March 6th)
• Steel and Aluminum taxed at 25% globally, which started on March 12th

Proposed for early April:

• 25% tax on goods compliant with the USMCA (this has been delayed, but may start April 2nd)
• Reciprocal tariffs with all countries taxed at the same rate
• Whatever a country charges us to export to them, we will charge them to import here.
• Agricultural goods globally will be tariffed (April 2nd)
• Autos and auto parts globally will be taxed 25% or more (April 3rd)

What It All Means

It is anyone’s guess how this all ends, what changes, what gets dropped, or what gets added in the next days weeks, or longer.

But what is clear is that the Trump administration is fulfilling the campaign promises he made, which is to leverage tariff policy for negotiations, increased revenue, balancing trade imbalances, and other areas they feel important.

The other key point in all of this is to listen, learn, understand and really think through how you may be allocated or positioned in your portfolio to protect yourself from any future turmoil. But one thing that would not be wise is to just blindly sell everything on these news headlines, because what we have seen for the first two months, is that things can change rapidly.

Conclusion

Tariffs are a complex tool in global trade, with both positive and negative consequences. While they can protect domestic industries, preserve jobs, and generate government revenue, they can also lead to higher consumer prices, trade tensions, and inefficiencies in the global market. The key to effectively using tariffs lies in balancing protectionist policies with the broader goals of economic welfare, international cooperation, and sustainable growth.

As global economies become more interconnected, the debate over the role of tariffs will continue to evolve. Policy makers must carefully consider the potential long-term impacts of tariffs on both domestic industries and global economic dynamics.

‍

References:

https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691117300/free-trade-today?srsltid=AfmB OooehD7Yfr4MDz_I9n1YlbGi-HCBZsF9Rudh_PfSOsJo6ni38KIB

https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691058962/against-the-tide?srsltid=AfmB OoqjMKr_x42XZYXMH2oLRyh9Kfdy8rY5VJ8wnw4XyxdKBapT-BW5

https://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/tpr_e/tpr_e.htm